es rápido, correo opcional y desactiva los anuncios.

Ser/Estar

Esto es una discusión · 21 respuestas
1 2 3
:

1.- Juan enfadado con el mundo.


2.- Madrid en el centro de España.


3.- muy simpático, pero ahora enfadado.


4.- En el centro de la ciudad la plaza grande.


5.- ¿Dónde la farmacia?


6.- triste porque un aburrido


Miembro Avanzado3,238
SystemAdministrator: A system administrator takes care of the inner workings of the entire system. These users have the ability to promote, ban and modify other users.
:
hmmm, muy dificil!
Usuario Regular189
Anonymous:
siete sobre ocho Emotion: smile
:
Wow, 8 out of 8! I didn't really expect that of myself. Emotion: surprise
Usuario Frecuente414
Trusted Users: Trusted users are allowed to use additional capabilities of the site such as private messaging to all users and various other advanced features. You cannot join this role unless you are promoted by an administrator.
:
Just a quick question - I thought "Es" was the conjugation of Estar when referring to something permanent and "Está" was to refer to something non'permanent? In ths case, why is number 2 in the test above Está?
Usuario Nuevo03
:
I'll probably sound like a nerd Emotion: geeked but my textbook says that, talking about the location of men, geographic objects (addresses), and the location of other things, we should use "estar".

I didn't get it at first either, but now I realize it's correct and logical: an address of an office (restaurant, bank, etc) can change, and also the capital of a county can be changed, too. Hence, these things are not really permanent, and we should use "estar".

Talking about #2 specifically, I think it's "estar" because the city can be renamed, or the name "Madrid" can be assigned to another town, etc. So it's not a permanent condition, even though these "manipulations" are not likely to happen.
Trusted Users: Trusted users are allowed to use additional capabilities of the site such as private messaging to all users and various other advanced features. You cannot join this role unless you are promoted by an administrator.
:
Hmm, but it talks about the location of the city which I would assume to be permanent Emotion: smile But I see what you mean regarding the name etc. Thanks for your quick response Emotion: smile
:
funkcannait talks about the location of the city which I would assume to be permanent
Yep, I had the same doubt at first, but now I've just memorized that locations of geographic objects are always described with "estar". Emotion: smile
Trusted Users: Trusted users are allowed to use additional capabilities of the site such as private messaging to all users and various other advanced features. You cannot join this role unless you are promoted by an administrator.
:
Thanks for that - ill remember that too Emotion: smile
Mostrar más
Cosas interesantes

Asuntos relacionados:

Spanish letters on an English keyboardEl cuento más corto del mundoMatrimonio civil vs. matrimonio religioso¿Qué es el Amor?Gloria Estefan¿Se debe enseñar el vosotros y sus...Títulos de películas en españolPoema sobre la poesía - Ricardo PalmaPrimer poema de César VallejoComo armar un curriculum vitae para trabajar¿Debería ser el español un...Homosexualidad¿Última película que viste?Big PharmaPenélope CruzReport scammers!Pictures you took - best and recentDos polemicas...Problemas al agregar amigosSpam spam spam spam spam spam...

Become a fan of Forodeespanol

 

Places to start

Find new friends

Community Sites

Browse forodeespanol


Help