Preterite vs. Imperfect

   Share on Facebook  
Anonymous  #11052  Sun, 01 Oct 06 01:37 AM
I have a major problem of figuring out in sentences wether a preterite congugation goes there or an imperfect congugation goes there.  Is there any way to help choose which one?  How do you know what to use?
  
Syl  #11087  Mon, 02 Oct 06 07:50 AM

Well, there are lots of rules for preterite and imperfect to find on the net. Even though I have read them I still find it hard sometimes to choose so I understand you. You can look at these links, maybe they help you a bit on the way.

http://www.forodeespanol.com/Archive/PreteriteAndImperfect/ckw/Post.htm

http://www.forodeespanol.com/Archive/PreteritoImperfectoEjercicio/cbxg/Post.htm

http://www.forodeespanol.com/Archive/PreteriteVsImperfect/bwnj/Post.htm

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on 22-02-2006
Miembro Pleno (881)
Trusted Users
¡Siempre son bienvenidas sus correcciones!
Aleksandra  #11135  Tue, 03 Oct 06 08:46 AM

Well, the simplest rule there is, is the following:

1) You use Preterire for actions that happened and finished in the past - so preterite is the equivalent of the simple past in English

2) Imperfect in Spanish is the equivalent of the past continuous in English, which means that any action that had a period of duration in the past and that did not happen only once will be expressed with a countinuous tense, i.e. with imperfect. The key is DURATION.

- You use Imperfect for actions that happened AND LASTED FOR A PERIOD OF TIME in the past

"The phone was ringing" (a countinuous action in the past, it kept ringning and ringing)unlike preterite "The phone rang" (it rang one time and stopped, no duration in the past)

- for actions that were habitual in the past (and that were usually annoing)

"Ella se cuejaba siempre" - She was always complaining"

- when you are narrating something, telling a story or describing an event:

"Era una mujer muy linda, tenia ojos .."

- for an action that was in progress when someting else happened:

"I was talking to Maria when he came into the room". - "(Yo ablaba cuando el entro..." - "was talking" is something that had a period of duration in the past, while "he came" is an action that happened only once in the past and lasted a minute, there was no duration in the past)

- for 2 simultaneous actions that happened and lasted in the past:

"I was cooking while she was cleaning." -  "Yo cocinaba mientras ella limpiaba" (for both cooking and cleaning you need time, they are actions that lasted in the past)

I don't know whether I expressed myself clear enough, but hopefully it will help.

Ciao

  
Top 100 Contributor
Joined on 29-09-2006
europe
Usuario Principiante (21)
Malta  #11191  Wed, 04 Oct 06 09:08 PM

I found this very helpful  Rose

http://www.studyspanish.com/tutorial.htm

  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on 28-08-2006
Miembro Pleno (598)
Trusted Users
Syl  #11193  Wed, 04 Oct 06 10:07 PM
Malta

I found this very helpful  Rose

http://www.studyspanish.com/tutorial.htm

It sure is a helpfull site Yes I still use it.

  
Jacksta The Man  #19943  Mon, 10 Dec 07 05:11 PM
I like the excersizes.
  
Top 150 Contributor
Joined on 06-12-2007
Usuario Principiante (17)
Anonymous  #29591  Thu, 06 Mar 08 04:06 AM
 

you just have to look at what the sentence is saying. preterite is the completion of an action and imperfect is continuing or habitual action. just read it and see what makes sense

 

  
Anonymous  #30888  Mon, 14 Apr 08 02:32 AM
i have no clue buddy i'm in the same dang boat as you.
  
Anonymous  #31928  Mon, 02 Jun 08 11:20 PM

I am a spanish teacher at Glastonbury, CT high school.....  

you can use both of the tenses for the past. you use imperfect is used for ongoing or repeated actions. The preterite is used for actions that have already been completed in the past. It can also can describe how a person felt about the past.

i hope this has been helpful! Good luck in the future useing preterite and imperfect! Smile

  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: Gramática - General Spanish grammar questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service